The Flavor Brief: The secret to silky tomato soup isn't the tomatoes


The Flavor Brief

A weekly letter about food, science, and why things taste the way they do

Read Past Newsletters

This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Hi Reader ,

For the longest time, I assumed the secret to chilled tomato soup was finding the best tomatoes.

I was lucky enough to have plenty to test that theory this summer. After months of watering, protecting, and occasionally worrying over my tomato plants, they rewarded me with more Sungolds than I knew what to do with. Some went into salads and into a version of sun-dried tomatoes. Some disappeared straight off the vine. And many ended up in this soup.

Somewhere along the way, though, I realized I'd been obsessing over the wrong ingredient.

This recipe has quickly become one of my favorite summer lunches. It's refreshing, surprisingly filling, and comes together in minutes. But the ingredient that transforms it from blended tomatoes into a silky, satisfying meal isn't the tomato.

It's stale bread.

It sounds backwards. Until you understand what's happening.

First, the recipe.

Then I'll show you why it works—and why you'll probably never look at stale bread the same way again.

This week's recipe is available exclusively to my core group of Flavor Files + subscribers. Interested in learning more? Scroll on!

HERE'S ONE IDEA FROM THIS WEEK'S ISSUE

Why Stale Bread Makes this soup Silky

Like traditional salmorejo and many classic gazpachos, this soup gets its silky body from stale bread. As bread stales, it loses moisture and its starches reorganize, allowing the crumb to readily reabsorb liquid when blended with the tomatoes and water. The hydrated starch and finely dispersed bread particles increase the soup's viscosity, transforming what would otherwise be thin tomato water into a smooth, velvety purée. Fresh bread doesn't work as well because its higher moisture content produces a pastier texture rather than the lighter silkiness of stale bread. The bread also helps stabilize the emulsion by increasing viscosity, much like the role of an egg yolk in mayonnaise or beurre blanc, even though it isn't acting as a true emulsifier itself.

Unlock every issue of The Flavor Files +
Get exclusive recipes, more in-depth food science, kitchen experiments, and thoughtful essays you won't find anywhere else.
Bonus through book launch
Inside Fundamentals of Flavor
An exclusive paid letter series about the six-year journey of researching, writing, testing, and photographing the book.
Become a paid subscriber →

Paid subscribers also learned

✓ Why toasted coriander tastes completely different after toasting.

✓ Why Kashmiri Chile makes food look spicy without making it spicy.

✓ Why warm toppings make cold food taste better.

✓ A kitchen experiment to try this weekend.

✓ Essays on how to become a better cook.

These newsletters have completely changed the way I cook.
Elijah P.

Go deeper with Fundamentals of Flavor

If you enjoy the way I teach in these newsletters, you'll find the same approach across 100 recipes and dozens of cooking principles in Fundamentals of Flavor.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Flavor Files

Food tastes better when you understand why it works. Science-backed recipes, flavor principles, and kitchen insights — every week. I host Flavor Forward on America's Test Kitchen and In The Test Kitchen on Netflix.

Read more from The Flavor Files
uly 2016 San Francisco Chronicle Food + Home cover showing Nik Sharma’s hands slicing dark red cherries, introducing his A Brown Kitchen column with the headline “American dreams.”

The Flavor Files + THE MAKINGS OF FUNDAMENTALS OF FLAVOR III I never planned to become a food writer. Read Past Newsletters This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader, Two weeks ago, I told you why Fundamentals of Flavor took six years to write. Last week, I shared why the book exists. This week, I want to tell you about the moment I left...

chicken lemon

The Flavor Brief A weekly letter about food, science, and why things taste the way they do Read Past Newsletters This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader I just flew back from Boston after wrapping the final few episodes of my show, Flavor Forward. The smoke from the wildfires in Canada tinted the light this warm, hazy yellow, which made...

The Flavor Files + THE MAKINGS OF FUNDAMENTALS OF FLAVOR: II The world doesn’t need another cookbook. An exclusive seven-part series for paid subscribers. This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader The world doesn’t need another cookbook. I told myself that over and over before I pitched Fundamentals of Flavor to my agent and publisher. There...