The Flavor Brief: Why your spices need fat before they need heat


The Flavor Brief

A weekly letter about food, science, and why things taste the way they do

Read Past Newsletters

This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Hi Reader

I just flew back from Boston after wrapping the final few episodes of my show, Flavor Forward.

The smoke from the wildfires in Canada tinted the light this warm, hazy yellow, which made filming trickier than usual. The video team's fix was almost more interesting than the problem: they tinted the color of the light inside the studio to match the natural light outside, which I learned made it much easier to color correct later in editing.

It was a good reminder that while the show is about cooking, there's a whole group of people behind the scenes who spend days editing and fine tuning every single episode to get it right. People sourcing ingredients and making sure there are swaps ready so we can do multiple takes if we need to. People timing every stage of prep so the final dish looks exactly how it should, based on the recipe as tested and written.

And when you're watching eight or ten minutes of a show pass by seamlessly on television, it's easy to forget how much work, and how many people, went into making it look that easy.

So thank you to everyone at America's Test Kitchen behind this show. It would not exist without you.

Last Sunday, I baked a plum cake to take full advantage of stone-fruit season. The bright blood-red juices of the plum bled through the cake in the most glorious way, creating a river-like pattern that made it even more enticing to slice through. I knew the red stains would be where the fruity flavors lay.

Our obsession with food colors has been around for a long time. And right now, the food industry is fighting one of its hardest battles yet: finding a natural red that works.

Everyone assumes this fight is about Red 40, the synthetic dye getting all the regulatory attention. But according to Kalsec scientist Christina Cuddihy, in an interview with FoodNavigator, the real problem child isn't synthetic. It's carmine, the deep red pigment made from crushed cochineal insects: stable through heat, stable across a wide pH range, stable for months on the shelf. Nothing plant-based has matched it yet.

Here's why: the natural reds we do have, like black carrot, beetroot, and elderberry, get their color from anthocyanins, and anthocyanins are moody. They hold their red only in low-pH, acidic conditions. Push the pH higher, and they drift toward purple, then fade. Beetroot has its own problem: under high heat, it oxidizes and browns, which is exactly what you want in plant-based meat and exactly what you don't want in a cracker or a candy.

So my plum cake's dramatic red bleed wasn't a fluke. It was pH and acidity doing exactly what food scientists wish they could bottle and keep stable for a long time.

Funny enough, that's not so different from what the video team was doing in Boston: chasing the same true color under conditions working against them. Turns out whether it's wildfire smoke or a hot oven, getting color right is never as simple as it looks.

xx

Nik

THE SCIENCE EDIT

THIS WEEK'S PRINCIPLE

WHY YOU SHOULD NEVER ADD SPICES STRAIGHT TO WATER

Most of what makes a spice taste like itself is fat-soluble, not water-soluble, so if you add cumin straight to a simmering pot of dal, most of its flavor never makes it into the dish. Bloom that same spice in hot oil first, and the fat pulls those aromatic compounds out and carries them through everything else you cook, so the fix is simple: before adding a spice, check if there's fat in the step yet, and if not, toast it in a spoonful of oil first. It's the same principle behind why a tadka works, and it's one of the ideas Fundamentals of Flavor is built around, the forces (fire, earth, air, water) behind why food tastes the way it does.

Read the full piece on cooking principles →

( Photo: My Tandoori Chicken © Nik Sharma - Fundamentals of Flavor | Chronicle Books - 2026)

On Shelves September 22

Fundamentals of Flavor just made Kitchen Arts & Letters' Fall Featured Preorders, alongside books from Danny Meyer, Rose Levy Beranbaum, and Josh Niland. That's not a list I take lightly.

The book itself is 100 recipes built around the science of why cooking works, not just what to do. If you've been asking "but why does this work" in my newsletter for a while, this is that question, answered, recipe by recipe.

On screen this week

AMERICA'S TEST KITCHEN

As a Southern California resident, tacos are a big part of my weekly diet. In this week's episode, we're talking about birria tacos, tacos dorados, and Okinawan taco rice.

THE RECIPEs

This week, I'm cooking things that come together faster than you'd think.

TATER TOT ALOO TIKKI CHAAT

This is chaat for people who want maximum flavor payoff for minimal effort: crispy tater tots standing in for aloo tikki, doused in yogurt, two chutneys, and a hit of chaat masala.

SPICED CHICKPEA CASHEW BURGERS

The secret to a veggie burger that doesn't crumble on you? Skip the wet binders and let starch do the work—chickpeas, instant potato flakes, and mayo team up for a patty with real bite and buttery dep

Get the full recipe hosted at ATK

Unlock every issue of The Flavor Files +

Get exclusive recipes, more in-depth food science, kitchen experiments, and thoughtful essays you won't find anywhere else.

Bonus through book launch

Inside Fundamentals of Flavor

Paid subscribers get essays from the book before anyone else, plus a running look at what's cooking, the ideas and dishes taking shape behind the scenes.

Become a paid subscriber →

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Flavor Files

Food tastes better when you understand why it works. Science-backed recipes, flavor principles, and kitchen insights — every week. I host Flavor Forward on America's Test Kitchen and In The Test Kitchen on Netflix.

Read more from The Flavor Files
uly 2016 San Francisco Chronicle Food + Home cover showing Nik Sharma’s hands slicing dark red cherries, introducing his A Brown Kitchen column with the headline “American dreams.”

The Flavor Files + THE MAKINGS OF FUNDAMENTALS OF FLAVOR III I never planned to become a food writer. Read Past Newsletters This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader, Two weeks ago, I told you why Fundamentals of Flavor took six years to write. Last week, I shared why the book exists. This week, I want to tell you about the moment I left...

The Flavor Files + THE MAKINGS OF FUNDAMENTALS OF FLAVOR: II The world doesn’t need another cookbook. An exclusive seven-part series for paid subscribers. This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader The world doesn’t need another cookbook. I told myself that over and over before I pitched Fundamentals of Flavor to my agent and publisher. There...

The Flavor Brief A weekly letter about food, science, and why things taste the way they do Read Past Newsletters This newsletter may contain some affiliate links. I only recommend things I personally use and enjoy—if you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Hi Reader , For the longest time, I assumed the secret to chilled tomato soup was finding the best tomatoes. I was lucky enough to have plenty to test that theory this summer. After months of...